Food Scene
Great place for coffee and lunch! They also have awesome sandwiches and offer plenty of take-out options. Nice to walk to from the rental!
6 locals recommend
Pultneyville Deli Company
4120 Lake RdGreat place for coffee and lunch! They also have awesome sandwiches and offer plenty of take-out options. Nice to walk to from the rental!
Fine dining in a RELAXED atmosphere! They feature over 100 martinis and Deanie Martini will be sure to make you something tasty! Tell her Jamie and Jason sent you!
This restaurant is seasonal.
13 locals recommend
The Bay Street
8427 Bay StFine dining in a RELAXED atmosphere! They feature over 100 martinis and Deanie Martini will be sure to make you something tasty! Tell her Jamie and Jason sent you!
This restaurant is seasonal.
Excellent dinner and drinks. Great bar with awesome bartenders! There is often live music, typically piano, as they even have one bar that surrounds a piano. The views of Lake Ontario are incredible as well.
This restaurant is seasonal.
9 locals recommend
Hedges Nine Mile Point Restaurant
1290 Lake RdExcellent dinner and drinks. Great bar with awesome bartenders! There is often live music, typically piano, as they even have one bar that surrounds a piano. The views of Lake Ontario are incredible as well.
This restaurant is seasonal.
Great stop for ice cream. One of the town trails even connects to their property so you can walk to it from the town park. Don't miss this stop!
This place is seasonal.
Yia Yia's Ice Cream Shoppe
3854 NY-104Great stop for ice cream. One of the town trails even connects to their property so you can walk to it from the town park. Don't miss this stop!
This place is seasonal.
Great food, great drinks, great people. This is a true locals hangout. Try the Franklin Plate...
10 locals recommend
Franklin House Tavern
8184 Sentell StGreat food, great drinks, great people. This is a true locals hangout. Try the Franklin Plate...
Great stop for breakfast or lunch. They are only open for dinner on Friday nights (try the Fish Fry!!). Breakfast all day on Saturday! Get there early to get a table.
All candy and chocolates are made on-site as they have been for decades. Iconic stop, for sure.
6 locals recommend
Original Candy Kitchen
4069 Main StGreat stop for breakfast or lunch. They are only open for dinner on Friday nights (try the Fish Fry!!). Breakfast all day on Saturday! Get there early to get a table.
All candy and chocolates are made on-site as they have been for decades. Iconic stop, for sure.
The Pizza Stop Pub and Bistro
4135 Lake RoadGreat pizza and a full bar. This is a local hangout!
This restaurant is about a 30-minute drive BUT SO WORTH IT! We've never had a bad meal and look forward to every visit. Check out the menu online as it's frequently updated. The wine pairings are excellent and the chef is fabulous.
Warfield's Restaurant, Lounge & Bakery
7 W Main StThis restaurant is about a 30-minute drive BUT SO WORTH IT! We've never had a bad meal and look forward to every visit. Check out the menu online as it's frequently updated. The wine pairings are excellent and the chef is fabulous.
This is a must-stop while visiting. It's been a staple of our community for decades and had the best breakfasts and chocolates around!
6 locals recommend
Original Candy Kitchen
4069 Main StThis is a must-stop while visiting. It's been a staple of our community for decades and had the best breakfasts and chocolates around!
Parks & Nature
B. Forman Park
4507 Lake RdAwesome sunsets here! Great for families and picnics.
Free public beach with plenty of parking and amazing views. There is a snack shack on site for quick and easy lunches!
24 locals recommend
Sodus Point Beach Park
7958 Wickham BlvdFree public beach with plenty of parking and amazing views. There is a snack shack on site for quick and easy lunches!
Pultneyville Mariners Inc
4161 Mill StPrivate beach membership required.
Great park for families. Playground, disc golf, ball fields, and walking trails.
Williamson Town Park
3793 Eddy RoadGreat park for families. Playground, disc golf, ball fields, and walking trails.
ENTRANCE AT THE END OF HAMILTON STREET EXTENSION (dirt road north of the Schoolhouse).
This is the second entrance to the preserve. This one is perfect for an easy entry to the water!
Cornwall Preserve
3975 Lake RdENTRANCE AT THE END OF HAMILTON STREET EXTENSION (dirt road north of the Schoolhouse).
This is the second entrance to the preserve. This one is perfect for an easy entry to the water!
Arts & Culture
Williamson-Pultneyville Historical Society
4130 Mill StMake sure to check out the ship wreck exhibits!
This is the oldest continuously active little theatre in America, and it's across the street from the Schoolhouse!
Check the gatesingers (dot) com schedule to catch a show while you're here.
Gates Hall
4107 Lake RoadThis is the oldest continuously active little theatre in America, and it's across the street from the Schoolhouse!
Check the gatesingers (dot) com schedule to catch a show while you're here.
Drinks & Nightlife
Apple Country Spirits
3274 Eddy RdGreat spirits and cider make with locally grown products.
Young Sommer Winery
4287 Jersey RdGreat stop for excellent local wines.
Fairly new restaurant/bar in town. Was built in an iconic historic building on Main Street.
Copper Ale House
4095 Ridge RdFairly new restaurant/bar in town. Was built in an iconic historic building on Main Street.
Boom Point
7483 Salmon Creek RdA new winery!
Embark Craft Ciderworks
6895 Lake AveVery close cidery with live music.
Adam’s Rascal’s Bar & Grill
5708 Ridge RoadLocal dive bar with wing specials on Thursday nights!
The views from the top deck are great. The drinks are good. Lots of live music!
22 locals recommend
Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern
8505 Greig StThe views from the top deck are great. The drinks are good. Lots of live music!
Sightseeing
Erie Canal
Erie Canal Heritage TrailCheck out the Erie canal!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iLfGSXuHu5g
Really easy walking trail right in Pultneyville. Gorgeous vistas and nice for families. Is also a good picnic place, but there are not tables. Pack a blanket!
Cornwall Preserve
3975 Lake RdReally easy walking trail right in Pultneyville. Gorgeous vistas and nice for families. Is also a good picnic place, but there are not tables. Pack a blanket!
Activities
Private disc golf course. We've been told it's an excellent course and just a couple miles away from Pultneyville!
Pfrommer Woods
7161 Townline RoadPrivate disc golf course. We've been told it's an excellent course and just a couple miles away from Pultneyville!
Rent kayaks and canoes here! Explore Sodus Bay!
Only 15 minutes from Pultneyville!
Sodus Bay Outfitters
Rent kayaks and canoes here! Explore Sodus Bay!
Only 15 minutes from Pultneyville!