Food scene
Grocery Store (downtown Sag Harbor) - Excellent grocery store for organic and fresh foods, also has a lovely cafe with a full menu of organic, breakfast and lunch foods (also vegetarian and vegan friendly options)
46 locals recommend
Provisions
7 Main StGrocery Store (downtown Sag Harbor) - Excellent grocery store for organic and fresh foods, also has a lovely cafe with a full menu of organic, breakfast and lunch foods (also vegetarian and vegan friendly options)
Grocery Store(downtown Sag Harbor, about 3 miles away) is a great grocery store, has just about everything you could need from produce to meats, prepared meals.
42 locals recommend
Schiavoni's Market Inc.
48 Main StGrocery Store(downtown Sag Harbor, about 3 miles away) is a great grocery store, has just about everything you could need from produce to meats, prepared meals.
Farm Stand (.5 miles from the house) - has great fresh and usually local essentials (milk, eggs, bread, fruits, veggies, chips, meat etc...)
26 locals recommend
Serene Green Inc.
3980 Noyack RdFarm Stand (.5 miles from the house) - has great fresh and usually local essentials (milk, eggs, bread, fruits, veggies, chips, meat etc...)
Fantastic Italian restaurant with cozy outdoor seating. Great pasta, cocktails and classy old school vibe.
38 locals recommend
DOPO La Spiaggia
6 Bay StFantastic Italian restaurant with cozy outdoor seating. Great pasta, cocktails and classy old school vibe.
Excellent bakery and best coffee we've had in town. New, friendly, great all around!
Carissa's the Bakery - Sag Harbor
Excellent bakery and best coffee we've had in town. New, friendly, great all around!
Restaurants
Sen
23 Main StSushi Restaurant (Main St. Sag Harbor) Great sushi restaurant
Italian Restaurant (Main St, downtown Sag Harbor) probably Sag Harbor's best and most sought after restaurant. If you don't have a reservation in-season, I recommend arriving right when they open for lunch or dinner. They can usually accommodate. Enjoy!
56 locals recommend
Tutto il Giorno Sag
16 Main StItalian Restaurant (Main St, downtown Sag Harbor) probably Sag Harbor's best and most sought after restaurant. If you don't have a reservation in-season, I recommend arriving right when they open for lunch or dinner. They can usually accommodate. Enjoy!
Frozen Yogurt (downtown Sag Harbor) Excellent frozen yogurt, take it and go for a stroll down the strip!
45 locals recommend
BuddhaBerry
125 Main StFrozen Yogurt (downtown Sag Harbor) Excellent frozen yogurt, take it and go for a stroll down the strip!
(downtown Sag Harbor) Best coffee in town with lite-bites, smoothies, a small menu of breakfast or lunch fare
48 locals recommend
Sagtown Coffee
78 Main St(downtown Sag Harbor) Best coffee in town with lite-bites, smoothies, a small menu of breakfast or lunch fare
Pizza Restaurant (downtown Sag Harbor) Great family pizza restaurant. Not a city style pizzeria with by the slice offerings, but a by-the-pie restaurant. Great for a family lunch or dinner!
59 locals recommend
Sag Pizza
103 Main StPizza Restaurant (downtown Sag Harbor) Great family pizza restaurant. Not a city style pizzeria with by the slice offerings, but a by-the-pie restaurant. Great for a family lunch or dinner!