Essentials
Stop & Shop
191 Montauk Hwynearest grocery store. 5 minute walk
awesome natural food market is a 1 minute walk from my place. They sell groceries as well as have a smoothie and juice bar and great prepared foods section.
7 locals recommend
Cornucopia Health Foods
35 N Main Stawesome natural food market is a 1 minute walk from my place. They sell groceries as well as have a smoothie and juice bar and great prepared foods section.
Food Scene
Starbucks
90 Main Stlocated right in the middle of town, its a 5-minute walk.
one of our best local restaurants. farm to table. historic building with tons of charm. outdoor sitting area. local bands.
Grey Horse Tavern
291 Bayport Aveone of our best local restaurants. farm to table. historic building with tons of charm. outdoor sitting area. local bands.
Artisanal Cheese Shop serving cheese, charcuterie, wine and beer. Take out available. Charming and AMAZING cheese selection. Owners are super accommodating and crazy knowledgeable.
American Cheese
Artisanal Cheese Shop serving cheese, charcuterie, wine and beer. Take out available. Charming and AMAZING cheese selection. Owners are super accommodating and crazy knowledgeable.
Quaint. Great coffee, smoothies, juices, lattes. Eggs, acai bowls. Many vegetarian options - soups, salads, sandwiches
The Golden Sparrow
570 Middle RoadQuaint. Great coffee, smoothies, juices, lattes. Eggs, acai bowls. Many vegetarian options - soups, salads, sandwiches
Italian Restaurant. 10 minute walk. Great wine list. Rice balls are fantastic. Live music and bar specials daily.
La Tavola
183 W Main StItalian Restaurant. 10 minute walk. Great wine list. Rice balls are fantastic. Live music and bar specials daily.
Cafe Joelle
45 Main StThe Fish Store
836 Montauk HwyBest seafood store around. Buy from the counter or sit in the restaurant.
Everything Else
Walgreens
102 N Main Stnearest pharmacy. 5 minute walk
Drinks & Nightlife
Blackbirds' Grille
553 Old Montauk HwyGood menu. Good drinks. Live music.
One of my favorite Fire Island beaches. Very relaxed atmosphere and diverse crowd. The beach is not crowded and there are great restaurants, bars and lots of entertainment.
12 locals recommend
Cherry Grove
One of my favorite Fire Island beaches. Very relaxed atmosphere and diverse crowd. The beach is not crowded and there are great restaurants, bars and lots of entertainment.
Another great FI beach. The ferry for the Pines and Cherry Grove is 1 mile away - 20 minute walk or a quick cab ride.
14 locals recommend
Fire Island Pines
Another great FI beach. The ferry for the Pines and Cherry Grove is 1 mile away - 20 minute walk or a quick cab ride.
Parks & Nature
Captain Kayak
23 River RdKayak rentals
Unbelievably beautiful arboretum along the Connetquot River. See bald eagles and Osprey. The grounds are impeccable. The mansion and outbuildings are charming and well-maintained.
27 locals recommend
Bayard Cutting Arboretum
440 Montauk HwyUnbelievably beautiful arboretum along the Connetquot River. See bald eagles and Osprey. The grounds are impeccable. The mansion and outbuildings are charming and well-maintained.
Ferry leaves from Patchogue. Patchogue is a 15 minute car ride. Watch Hill is the other FI beach you can access from Patchogue Frry terminal. Free parking in the lot.
14 locals recommend
Davis Park
Ferry leaves from Patchogue. Patchogue is a 15 minute car ride. Watch Hill is the other FI beach you can access from Patchogue Frry terminal. Free parking in the lot.