Gift shop
Milk Pail
11 locals recommend,
Location
1346 Montauk Hwy
Water Mill, NY
Tips from locals
Local shop serving the worlds best cookies. They also sell wine, veggies, ready made frozen meals, and have a food truck outside if you fancy stopping by for lunch.
The Milk Pail Fresh Market began more than 30 years ago. John learned about farming growing up on his father’s Mecox potato farm while Evelyn got her first taste for apple growing from her parents’ apple orchard in Vermont. In 1969 they began a tiny retail store to market their vegetables and sell the milk produced by their cows. They named the store The Milk Pail, since milk was their main product at the time. The following spring they planted their apple orchard and have been perfecting and adding award-winning varieties ever since.
The Milk Pail Fresh Market began more than 30 years ago. John learned about farming growing up on his father’s Mecox potato farm while Evelyn got her first taste for apple growing from her parents’ apple orchard in Vermont. In 1969 they began a tiny retail store to market their vegetables and sell t…
Need local apples, cider wine etc... Stop here (Closed Tuesdays) for your fix on amazing food ready to go
Unique things to do nearby
Locals also recommend
- 7 locals recommend