Store
Big Olaf's Ice Cream
18 locals recommend,
Location
Sag Harbor, NY
Tips from locals
The best ice cream in Sag Harbor, open late at night over the summer, and lines move quickly. So many flavors and each one is better than the next!
Great ice cream and right next to the harbor. You can enjoy your ice cream and watch the boats.
The flavors are plentiful and the homemade waffle cones are scrumptious (even just the smell of them baking will make you drool).
Unique things to do nearby
Locals also recommend
- 63 locals recommend