Bar
Toby's Supper Club
14 locals recommend
Location
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd
Madison, WI
Tips from locals
Toby's is famous for their Friday night fish fry. Personally, it's not my favorite fish but the experience is worth it if you enjoy Wisconsin supper clubs and a good Old Fashioned. Be prepared for at least an hour long wait and know the system. 1. Walk in and go straight to the bar. Order an Old Fashioned and request a menu from the bartender. 2. A server will find you to take your order. 3. When your food is ready, the same server will find you to direct you to your table.
Toby's is famous for their Friday night fish fry. Personally, it's not my favorite fish but the experience is worth it if you enjoy Wisconsin supper clubs and a good Old Fashioned. Be prepared for at least an hour long wait and know the system. 1. Walk in and go straight to the bar. Order an Old…
A little bit of a drive, but worth it for a classic Wisconsin supper club. Enjoy a brandy old-fashioned sweet while waiting for your table. Great steaks and Friday fish fry.