Bakery
Bagel Buoy Market
18 locals recommend,
Permanently closed
Location
3 Bay St
Sag Harbor, NY
Tips from locals
Real NY style bagels used to be hard to find out here. Now they are easy, at Bagel Buoy. People mispronounce it as "Bagel Boy" but it is Bagel Buoy, ("Booey") you know, the things floating out there so boats know where to anchor? Marina park across the street is a nice, quiet place to sit and eat or have coffee. Please don't let kids chase the ducks! They have enough problems already. Quack!
Real NY style bagels used to be hard to find out here. Now they are easy, at Bagel Buoy. People mispronounce it as "Bagel Boy" but it is Bagel Buoy, ("Booey") you know, the things floating out there so boats know where to anchor? Marina park across the street is a nice, quiet place to sit and eat…
The owner is my friend and (me) having grown up in Brooklyn, New York - well I know my bagels and Darrin makes the best in town!!!