Restaurant
Shortstop Deli
18 locals recommend,
Location
200 W Seneca St
Ithaca, NY
Downtown
Tips from locals
Natalie & Stephen
June 9, 2017
Some of the best subs you'll ever have. Everything is made to order either at the counter or online. We love the Grand Slam-sized (pretty much 2 sandwiches in one) subs with local Suzie Seitan! Make sure to add a fountain drink for only 10 cents more. After you enjoy your sub, head over to Sweet Melissa's next door for dessert (in the summer season).
Linda
September 7, 2011
Fast local food. In summer there's an ice cream stand that has a coconut milk ice cream of the day.
Sarah
November 4, 2018
Always open! Easy walk.
Jessica
October 14, 2014
When everything is closed late at night, you always can depend on a shortstop PMP (poor man's pizza) or a delicious sub.
Murielle
May 29, 2021
About a block from your AirBnb, this is a local favorite counter-service deli. Great food at an affordable price and open late, this place is good for any meal.
