Skip to content
We’re sorry, some parts of the Airbnb website don’t work properly without JavaScript enabled.
Airbnb your home
Sign up
Log in
Gift cards
Airbnb your home
Host an experience
Help Center
Show Photos
Bakery
Fly By Night Cookie Co
10 locals recommend
Permanently closed
Location
14508 Fancher Ave
Fair Haven, NY
Get directions
Tips from locals
Lorrie
August 19, 2021
Cutest little house where the aromas draw you and the cookies are awesome!
Amy
June 22, 2016
A wonderful gem with the best cookies in the world.
Shirley/Larry
March 1, 2018
A Trip to Bonnie’s is always an adventure! Check for seasonal hours.
Marilynn
October 27, 2016
Amazing cookies and pies. Unique!!
Read all 10 tips
Locals also recommend
Bar
Brandon's Pub + Grille
10 locals recommend
Restaurant
Pleasant Beach Hotel
10 locals recommend
Bar
Little Sodus Inn
9 locals recommend
Restaurant
Turtle Cove Resort & Marina
7 locals recommend
Bakery
Tops Friendly Markets
6 locals recommend
Show more