Store
Not My Dads Soft Serve
12 locals recommend,
Permanently closed
Location
203 E Main St
Trumansburg, NY
Tips from locals
SEASONAL NMD is at the South end of Main St past the Schools across from Byrne Dairy. Always great treats!
Trumansburg does not lack ice-cream options in the summertime and Not My Dad's is a safe bet on a hot day. Located between the Trumansburg Schools and the fairgrounds, it's also very popular.