Bakery
IGA Shelter Island
28 locals recommend
Location
75 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY
Tips from locals
A charming local grocery store, what more could you want? Oh yeah, there's also a totally idiosyncratic (but totally cool!) streetwear boutique inside (the owner's son is a designer), as well as perhaps the best 70s/80s yacht rock playlist ever created. They stock a wide variety of must-haves and a few specialty items, as well as many other conveniences like firewood, paper plates, and bird seed. The deli counter serves Boar's Head and actually makes really excellent wraps and sandwiches.
A charming local grocery store, what more could you want? Oh yeah, there's also a totally idiosyncratic (but totally cool!) streetwear boutique inside (the owner's son is a designer), as well as perhaps the best 70s/80s yacht rock playlist ever created. They stock a wide variety of must-haves and a…