Cafe
Cayuga Lake Creamery
44 locals recommend,
Location
8421 NY-89
Interlaken, NY
Tips from locals
If you bring a car and drive out here, you won't regret it. Some of the best ice cream around!
Just the best ice cream in the world. On the west side of Cayuga Lake after Taughanock Park on Rte 89. Local. No gelatin.