Restaurant
Commander Cody's Seafood
22 locals recommend,
Location
41 Smith St
Shelter Island, NY
Tips from locals
Em
July 7, 2022
This is a bit of a dive, but a fun experience. Does mostly take out, but has a few seats. Great fried chicken and fish. They also have a fish market.
Suzette
August 5, 2020
Great fresh fish and take out or eat in. Very local. Favorite dishes are fried shrimp, lobster, soups, fried chicken. Southern style Walking distance from my Airbnb
Kathryn
July 31, 2018
Great seafood takeout. Or sit and enjoy a meal and BYOB
Raz
July 21, 2017
1 block walking from house
Sue
May 25, 2022
Fresh fish market and lobster tank. Take out only, if you like fried shrimp and clams, this is the place. You can see their specials on their Facebook page (20+) Commander Cody's Seafood | Facebook
