Store
Hickory Hill Market
62 locals recommend,
Location
5200 NY-23
Windham, NY
Tips from locals
Not your typical gas station - it has an excellent beer cave, a deli, pizza takeout, groceries, a surprisingly good selection of cheeses (an entire case!) and fresh fruits and vegetables. A lot more like a mini supermarket. You can usually get fire wood here too.
Aside from groceries, you can also grab a hot pizza, salad, sandwich here. Want to make a charcuterie board? This is the place for that.
Great place to pick up sandwiches, beer, soda, ice cream, snacks, etc. Their pizza is good but don't take it to go. It tastes better hot out of the oven, and it only takes minutes to bake. There is a dining area with table choices including high top tables. The beer cave should have plenty of choices for the beer drinkers.