Point of interest
American Hotel
124 locals recommend,
Location
45 Main St
Sag Harbor, NY
Tips from locals
Iconic destination with one of the largest wine cellars. indoor and outdoor seating that overlooks main street
In the heart of Sag Harbor village on Main Street, Fresh local seafood and meats, this restaurant offers charming indoor and outdoor dining spaces. theamericanhotel.com
Amazing 19th Century Hotel. Another boozy old school scene for Lobster Bisque, Onion Soup, Fine wine, and Cigars. Its always fun to visit Sag Harbor
A historic classic. Food is always consistent. Covered sidewalk dining. Cold Lobster Salad is a must here! Service and decor is very old-school.
(631) 725 - 3535. This is a classic, local place. The bar scene tends to be a more mature crowd. If you are here during scallop season, which is not until November, you have to at least go to the bar and order a small plate of their scallops. They are excellently prepared, in a sauce with some special ingredient that I have yet to discern. Maybe you can get one of the bartenders to fill you in.
(631) 725 - 3535. This is a classic, local place. The bar scene tends to be a more mature crowd. If you are here during scallop season, which is not until November, you have to at least go to the bar and order a small plate of their scallops. They are excellently prepared, in a sauce with some speci…